East or West, What's Best?
Introductory Geography Lesson
I was tidying up some photographic files from a couple of years back, when I came across these two landscape pics.
I took them from two lookout spots, both on the flat plateau which is Mt Tamborine, just south of Brisbane in South-East Queensland. The locations are within a couple of kilometres of each other and the shots were taken within an hour or so of each other. The first one (Photo 1) looks directly east, following a late afternoon storm, which passed quickly overhead, down across the coastal plain on which the famous Gold Coast strip is located, then out to sea. The second (Photo 2) looks west towards the setting sun, across the Gold Coast Hinterland and the remnants of a huge 40km wide caldera or collapsed volcano.
During post processing I was prompted to think about the similarities and extremes of East and West; not just literally, as depicted by the points of the compass and the contents within each frame, but in the more general context of society, culture and their foundation philosophies.
Looking in Both Directions
Both shots have similarities at a brief overview. They both show dramatic skies above a varied and interesting landscape, with extremes of bright light and dark shade. But the details revealed in each frame are quite different and varied. How so then the similarities and differences between Eastern and Western philosophies and cultures?
Over my career of too many decades, I have been fortunate enough to both travel to and work in a variety of lands which I have sorted into three groups as follows:
- countries which are located within the birthplace or neighbouring influence of Eastern philosophy (China, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Sri Lanka);
- countries where Western philosophy developed and spread (Greece, Italy, France, Great Britain, Germany, Scandinavia); and
- countries where there has been a historic clash and/or merging of Eastern and Western cultures, either in past or recent times, or both (Saudi Arabia, Iraq, the Arabian Gulf States, North Africa, Turkey, Singapore and Hong Kong).
A Dose of Idealism
Many idealists have suggested that perhaps the human race is tending towards a uniformity of cultures and thinking, and that we are losing our individuality of self and heritage, in a huge melting pot of common tastes and convergence.
Perhaps, given enough time, hard work and inspiration, the melting pot may become reality. But not before we have learned to look after each other (by merging the 'haves' and 'have nots'); to look after our planet, to enable it to continue to sustain us; so that we can eventually learn how to provide ample food and clean drinking water for our surviving generations.
But, until we have progressed towards thinking macroscopically in terms of the human race, rather than limiting our needs and wants as relatively microscopic entities, then perhaps we should think about the well documented origins and workings of the main philosophies, East and West, which have formed what is more often a clash than a merging of cultures.
What are our Differences?
Here is a fool's guide to some of the origins, components and constituents of Eastern and Western Philosophies, which can be verified by a myriad of 'Googled' papers, each presenting remarkably similar results.
Firstly, let's summarise Western Philosophy:
- Developed by the ancient Greeks and then spread to other Europeans, and eventually to their colonies.
- Has its roots in science and rationale, with heavy use of logic, reasoning and categorisation, focusing on parts rather than the whole.
- Individually oriented, with self at the centre, being your 'own person', independent from the universe and society.
- Materialistic goals.
- Strives to find and prove the truth by analysis. If it can't be explained and proven it doesn't exist.
- Individual rights.
Compare then Eastern Philosophy:
- Developed in ancient China and India, spreading throughout Asia.
- Has its roots in religion (e.g. Confucianism, Zen Buddhism, Taoism, Yoga) and does not distinguish between philosophy and religion, unifying ideas into a greater whole.
- Group and society oriented, looking at the bigger picture, with the individual a small part of a greater ideal.
- Spiritual goals.
- Strives for harmony (yin and yang) with an inherent acceptance and without a need to prove.
- Social responsibility.
So What Can We Learn from Each Other?
With such radically different cultural bases, and following the flimsy argument that "opposites attract" rather than "let's knock the stuffing out of each other", wouldn't we expect that there may be lessons to be learned on both sides of the geographical divide? Having been brought up under the individualistic and materialistic influences of Western Society, I can see interesting and attractive benefits associated with eastern attitudes of harmony rather than conflict, society rather than self, and the setting of spiritual rather than materialistic goals. But what about the benefits of Western Society from an Eastern perspective? Are there any, or has the West merely corrupted Eastern minds into seeking an individual materialist middle class existence, with all its throw away toys, pollutants and self indulgence?
What do You think?
Am I and my future generations heading towards a melting pot, or am I and mine heading off in different directions?
Do I live in a fortress or a commune?
Do I shoulder social responsibility or walk the path of self advancement?
Do I have the choice of tap, still or sparkling?
Do I have to carry water on my head for four kilometres from the nearest well?
Am I bored of home cooked meals and eat out to break the boredom?
Am I happy to eat the same meagre staple diet, day in, day out?
Are my biceps toned?
Are my children dying of curable diseases?
Do I .....?
Do You .....?
or Should We .....?
............<<...........>>..............
When not researching the weird or the wonderful, the comical or the cultured, the sinful or the serious, I chase my creative side, the results of which can be seen as selected photographs of my travels on my website at:
http://ken-boddie.squarespace.com
The author of the above, Ken Boddie, besides being a consulting engineer, is an enthusiastic photographer, rarely leisure-travelling without his Canon, and loves to interact with other like-minded photographers and people with an artistic background.
Ken's three day work week (part time commitment) as a consulting engineer allows him to follow his photography interests, and to plan trips to an ever increasing list of countries and places of scenic beauty and cultural diversity.
"Articles from Ken Boddie
View blogThere's a part of Australia I've seen now and then, · Where the folks are resilient, both women and ...
I've been sleep deprived lately, so I thought I'd run around the bed several times to catch up on my ...
At last I was off to dinosaur country, that part of outback Queensland renowned in recent decades fo ...
Related professionals
You may be interested in these jobs
-
Travel Sales Consultant
Found in: Talent AU C2 - 5 days ago
Luxury Escapes Southbank, Australia Full timeHere at Luxury Escapes, our mission is to delight our customers with incredible deals for the world's best holidays. · We are a collective of forward-thinking people, driven to challenge the travel industry and ourselves to bring ever better travel experiences to our customer com ...
-
Mechanical Engineering Technician
Found in: Talent AU C2 - 6 days ago
GRiP Busselton, AustraliaAbout The Role: · The main duty of the position is to maintain mechanical equipment on site to achieve optimum availability and cost. · Reports to: · Mechanical Supervisor · Duties, Statements & Accountability: · Safe Systems of Work:Adhere to established safety protocols and pr ...
-
Area Sales Executive – Greater Toowoomba
Found in: JobGet AU C2 - 1 week ago
Western Union Brisbane City, AustraliaArea Sales Executive – Greater Toowoomba · Does playing a role in business growth sound exciting to you? Are you energized by developing leads into new clients? Would you like to work for a global company in Money Transfer that believes when money moves, better things can happen ...
Comments
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #34
Good luck with your self improvement, Manjit. I had become quite dismayed that so many societies are driven by wealth and power and had quite forgotten that improvement starts with 'I'.
CityVP Manjit
6 years ago #33
We should not be comparison shopping any philosophy but when we have large subject sets like east vs west, invariably it slides down into the debating rabbit hole. It is a rabbit hole because invariably when I have been involved in debating, I have never been taught to debate. Debating is a valid skill, and that is pathway for me to personally explore in the realm of critical thinking. IMHO parliamentary procedure is infuriating in terms of the speed of modern decision making and in the era of open systems, so I do find Roberts Rules antiquated and I do wish that governments used digital systems to vote instead of fearing that western civilization will collapse if they did not say aye or nay. I am product of holistic eastern culture and the processed product of a western education. It is the question in your title which asks "What's Best?" and I do take that as rhetorical question. I am extremely mindful of the Tyranny of OR and I see the value of the Power of AND. That is why for creative thinking development I want to explore improv. Improv has nothing do with east vs west. The reality of east vs west can be found in a modern Indian city, where the social scene makes the west look tame, for it is more west than the west. Then there is the whole new age movement or Ik Onkar that puts eastern philosophy on a pedestal and that is more east than the east. I can't make a better world from either debate or improv but I can create a wiser me. Millions of wiser people is what transforms this world but are many individuals invested that way?
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #32
Should we be debating whether Eastern or Western philosophy is best, Manjit, or should we rather be reviewing whether debate is the most effective tool for achieving advancement in today’s society? Born of Greek democratic roots, debate is by definition a Western concept, but does debate really improve our understanding of the options and achieve a logical conclusion of right and wrong, or does it more often draw out the decision making process to a stalemate? How often does the parliamentary system of debating truly represent a balance of the wishes of the people? Isn’t any real outcome dependent upon the numbers on and presentation skills of the predominant side? Taking the initiative of Eastern philosophy, how do we achieve what is best for state, country, or Mother Earth, rather than what is best for the most powerful collection of individuals represented at the debating chamber? I fear this question must remain rhetorical unless we are woken up by the onset of oblivion while there is still time to act.
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #31
CityVP Manjit
6 years ago #30
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #29
I’ll drink to that last sentence, Gert, and accept it unequivocally with my Eastern philosophical exposure, while ignoring my Western philosophical upbringing, which tempts me to analyse it. 😂
Gert Scholtz
6 years ago #28
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #27
Ah Vegemite, John! This product exemplifies the philosophical differences between East and West. Western culture (in this case primarily UK and Australia) has been fixated on the origins of and recipes for this black sticky gooey spread (a brewer's yeast derivative, copied from the English Marmite) and has failed to logically categorise this potent and sticky gunk into any of the main food groups. Eastern culture, however, has reportedly accepted without question its apparent benefits to society, as substantiated by a recent shortage of Vegemite in Hong Kong, the traditional Vegemite gateway into China, where demand recently outstripped the imported supply from the sole production factory in Port Melbourne. Furthermore, in Japan, demand for Vegemite stems from the black spread being rated “Umami” which is a Japanese word that literally "evokes a fifth sense of utmost deliciousness". Now since in Australia alone, Vegemite is reportedly spread on approximately 1.2 billion slices of toast, bread or biscuits every year, if such toast, bread or biscuits were all placed end to end, they would go around the world three times (as reported by "Twisted History" and certainly beyond the limitations of my own mathematics). Surely such a gargantuan amount of gluey gunk is enough to repair any divide, whether north south or east west, through practical rather than philosophical application? Personally I can neither stomach Vegemite nor Marmite, although I can see there may be some possibility of these products being used as an alternative road seal binder to bitumen, with or without the underlay of toast, bread or biscuits.
John Rylance
6 years ago #26
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #25
Didn’t know there was a north south divide, John. On the assumption that this rift is either pecuniary or cricket based, rather than my subject of philosophy, I am arranging for food parcels to be sent from Oz to UK. Will also ask my South African mates Gert Scholtz to organise a whip round for you guys. Incidentally, didn’t realise the North Koreans played cricket. 🤔
John Rylance
6 years ago #24
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #23
and will contine to be so, Franci\ud83d\udc1dEugenia Hoffman, beBee Brand Ambassador, until we learn to be less selfish and more socially aware. I’m not holding my breath on this, Franci.
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #22
I fear there is no ‘best’ anymore, John, as long as our minds continue to be raped by materialistc and individual lusts. But there again I live in a glass house.
Ken Boddie
6 years ago #21
Ian Weinberg ..... It seems quite clear, Each passing year, Brings melting pots of culture near. Oh dear, oh dear, I fear your fear, That eastern ways may disappear.
John Rylance
6 years ago #20
Ian Weinberg
6 years ago #19
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #18
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #17
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #16
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #15
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #14
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #13
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #12
Lisa Gallagher
7 years ago #11
Javier Cámara-Rica 🐝🇪🇸
7 years ago #10
Lisa Gallagher
7 years ago #9
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #8
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #7
Dean Owen
7 years ago #6
Gert Scholtz
7 years ago #5
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #4
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #3
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #2
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #1